16 Comments
User's avatar
Yoav Ravid's avatar

If reclamation counts as improvement, why do we need a special tax exemption for it? LVT already exempts improvements by definition.

Another approach I can think of is not to exempt reclamation value from taxation, but just directly reward private reclamation efforts, in a similar way to Norway paying natiral gas companies for search efforts.

For the rest of the series - I remeber Robbe argued in the conference that it's better to think of land as immovable rather than fixed in supply. And that if you consider the transport costs of every commodity and land, you get the same distinction between them. Might be worth mentioning or devoting a full article to this perspective. I haven't heard enough about it to make up my mind, so I'd curious to read about it in more detail.

ps. Nice alliteration: "People make pencils. People make popsicles. People make patios, plastic, plates, and posters. People even make PowerPoint presentations."

Yoav Ravid's avatar

Oh, also, if location is more fundamental than land, should we change our rhetoric and start saying "location" instead of "land? The acronyms would all stay the same, so it wouldn't be a big inconvenience.

Henry Law's avatar

Land created by reclamation must be continuously protected or the sea will take it back again. The cost of upkeep of the protective dykes and sea walls should be met by the owners of the protected land, preferably by a land value tax. If the value is less than the cost of the protection then the case for continued protected needs to be questioned. It could be more than the land is worth.

Dustin Pieper's avatar

I'd be curious to see the long term finance implications gamed out for an owner of the land.

To me, LVT is really there to factor in the community-derived value of the land more than anything, so an LVT could capture additional land value increases past the initial bump created by the new existence of said land. It might not be perfect, but it should help cover the maintenance cost.

Here's maybe a weird counter example. A skyscraper, in theory, is also creating more land in the form of additional floors. Put another way, it's reclaiming land not from the sea but from the sky. LVT would never consider taxing this "new land", so should reclaimed land follow the same logic? It's the base increase in valuation over time that we're most worried about, after all.

Lars Doucet's avatar

Skyscrapers and development potential will be covered in part three!

transformer's avatar

As you can see most of the property tax amendments are sponsored by Conservative Republicans. There are too many exemptions, tax breaks for older people in this state. It shows how deeply embedded the conservative values of the landed gentry and landowning interests are in this state.

This state has low taxes for oil and gas and they would never consider something like in Norway in how it recovers economic rent from its oil.

AI Summary

Louisiana does provide certain exemptions on severance taxes for oil and gas companies, particularly based on the price of oil and gas. For instance, if the price of oil is between $70 and $80 per barrel, an 80% exemption applies, meaning companies only pay severance tax on 20% of their production.

dam.ldr.la.gov

Tax Exemptions for Oil and Gas Companies

Louisiana's tax structure includes specific exemptions for oil and gas production.

Severance Tax Exemption — Companies may receive an 80% exemption on oil severance tax when prices are between $70 and $80 per barrel.

Natural Gas Tax Rates — Natural gas is taxed at a lower rate compared to oil, reflecting a different approach to taxation.

Production-Based Taxation — Severance taxes are generally based on the volume or value of resources extracted, impacting overall tax liability.

Regulatory Compliance — Companies must adhere to specific filing requirements to benefit from these exemptions.

Pelican Policy

AI Summary

Louisiana offers various tax exemptions for oil and gas production, particularly for natural gas, which can be exempted entirely under certain conditions. In contrast, Norway has a more complex tax structure that includes high taxes on oil and gas production, but also offers significant deductions and incentives for exploration and development costs.

Pelican Policy

+1

Tax Exemptions in Louisiana vs. Norway

Both Louisiana and Norway have distinct tax structures for oil and gas.

Louisiana's Severance Tax — Louisiana's severance tax on oil is currently 12.5%, but it will be reduced to 6.5% for new wells completed after June 30, 2025.

Natural Gas Exemption — Natural gas wells can receive a 100% exemption if prices are at or below $4.50 per million BTU.

Norway's Tax Structure — Norway imposes a 78% tax rate on oil companies, which includes a 22% corporate tax and a 56% special tax.

Deductions in Norway — Norwegian companies can deduct exploration and development costs, which can significantly lower their effective tax rate.

Comparative Benefits — While Louisiana offers exemptions, Norway's system incentivizes investment through deductions despite higher nominal tax rates.

transformer's avatar

Great article Lars Doucet, I live here in Louisiana and there is going to be an election next week on November 3, 2026 to decide 10 amendments; there are 6 amendments dealing with property taxes. I plan on voting No on those amendments but I would like your opinion and insights on Amendments 1, 2, 6, 8 ,9, and 10. Especially, Amendment 10 which offers property tax breaks to blighted property. I am suspicious of this amendment in particular. Read this:

https://ballotexplained.com/measures/louisiana/amendment-10

https://parlouisiana.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Fall-2026-Amendment-Guide-One-Pager.pdf

https://parlouisiana.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/PAR-Guide-to-the-Fall-2026-Constitutional-Amendments.pdf

EDIT: I just discovered this when I did an AI search on Yahoo Search Engine:

I didn't know that it establishes that for qualifying residential property, not more than 75% of the

assessed value of the property may be exempted from ad valorem taxation for a period not

to exceed 20 years

https://www.legis.la.gov/Legis/ViewDocument.aspx?d=1485013

Flume, Nom de's avatar

If people thought that skyscrapers would last indefinitely into the future without maintenance...

Then you'd have an improvement that was effectively an artificially constructed, geologically stable, weirdly shaped, mountain.

Dustin Pieper's avatar

A mountain is usually still just inhabited on the surface, though, meaning that it doesn't intensify land use at all. Especially since it's hard to build on.

Unless you're envisioning some sort of dwarven city kinda thing! I wouldn't be against it, so long as we don't dig too deep...

Citizen's Dividend's avatar

Even when engineering expands our physical footprint—like the Dutch reclaiming land from the sea—prime location value remains a shared social resource. When private entities capture unearned land rents, it fuels speculation and housing crises.

To build a more equitable economy, that public wealth should benefit everyone. Learn more about how Citizen's Dividend can shift toward shared resource revenues works at https://citdiv.org

Ryan's avatar

I really glad I found this substack and discussion

This piece left me unconvinced we've found the right treatment yet, despite being a huge fan of LVT generally.

First of all, just as land can be "reclaimed" from the sea, we have places where land is being "unclaimed" (wrong word?) back into the sea through erosion. There's a natural foil here. How would unclaimed land be treated? Would someone have to pay a fine for allowing their land to be turned back into "water land"? Or could they enjoy ongoing reclamation subsidies though poor protection of their land and endless reclamation cycles?

Second, I'm not convinced "place" is really the right term. Sure, unimproved land may be a "place", but a high rise can feel like several or many "places" - each floor is creating more "place" in a sense.

Another bit of the article says the reclaimed land should "ideally be kept publicly owned". I don't see how this is obvious at all. While public ownership and ground rent maybe equivalent from a financial/tax perspective, I'd have big concerns about publicly owned land becoming subject to politically captured uses. When land is privately owned and taxed, there's a natural tension that makes sure taxes don't get unreasonably high (private owners will abandon) or too low (governments want tax revenue). When land is owned by government, maybe it gets zoned so a politically favored entity is the only one who can feasibly rent it and thus revenue is kept low.

I haven't thought too deeply about this all yet so I might be missing a lot. I would love to converse with more like minded people about these things.

The Land Scout's avatar

The improvement-vs-site framing matches what shows up in ordinary rural land deals: county assessors separately value the cleared pad, the well, the driveway and the septic, and buyers routinely overpay for "improved" lots where the improvements are worth less than claimed. Your time-decay point fits too. A decades-old road base or culvert really has merged into the site by then.

Related edge case the series might touch: land moving the other direction. Erosion, subsidence and sea-level rise quietly unmake land, and owners of riverine and coastal parcels deal with that as a real carrying cost.

Romulus binge pattern's avatar

Do we need a Magic: the Gathering land valuation system?

Chris Parker's avatar

The same logic can apply to very long lived infrastructure that creates large economic rents, such as major dams creating electricity, airports, ports. That’s also why they’re more likely to be publicly owned

Kalle Pihlajasaari's avatar

I believe that the income to the state from land taxes should be shared with all Adult Resident Citizens as a Dividend (ARCD). This way the adult citizens who have made the social contract with their country and live there are rewarded. It also means that for a private individual there is NO BURDEN from LVT because they receive more as a dividend than they have to pay for their own parcel that they live on.

Dustin Pieper's avatar

I've thought about this as a sort of "Physical Space Dividend". Or in a less weird and nerdy way, a "Shelter Dividend".

Basically, all humans need some amount of physical space just to exist passively. We really can't help it on account of having corporeal bodies and all. So there should be some dividend to effectively account for that, some nominal value of existence. More realistically, you could probably tie it to the average land cost of the average dwelling (including apartments) in the country or territory under consideration. In other words, it would exempt the literal cost of living for all people equally, and if folks want to live beyond that in some way they can pay the additional cost. And if they live below that, they get to enjoy the surplus.